I'm not saying this to make you feel bad or make the situation worse for you. I'm quilty of this myself with these damn phones. Be it a phone or camera, it is best to keep distractions to a minimum while on stand. You are exactly right we work to damn hard to not bring our a game. For me, that includes minimizing distractions. Things happen so fast, if you don't have that mental edge happeni g at the shot, the quality of the shot decreases.
I'm not saying this to cut you, it is a reminder to myself because I am guilty of distracting myself.
Hopefully you grazed him and the dual isn't over
And the other part that really pisses me off! is I had the camera on record when I thought I had shut it off. I clipped on my release and hit the record button and that shut it off when I thought I just turned it on, Right before I shot! :mad:
Just plain stupid!
Sorry MO...I don't care who you are or what anyone says. You hunt long enough and have enough opportunities and bad things will happen sometimes. When it happens to me, I allow myself to beat the snot out of me for 1 day, do my best to learn something from it and then do my best to stop pummeling myself over it. the best thing you could do, IMO, is get out there and roll a doe ASAP. Does wonders for getting the mind right again (for me at least), and bowhunting is sooooooooooooo much more mental than we give it credit for.
P.S. If your descriptions of events are accurate (I know as well as any that things happen fast and not always exactly as they appear), odds are you didn't kill him and he won't be impacted long term over this. You most likely went over the spine and gave him a really bad deep muscle scratch, but nothing that will impact him long term. He'll most likely be breeding in a little over a month from now.
Deer are pretty tough.
Depending on shot angle, it's also possible you just clipped the top of both lungs...or 1 and center punched the other. A study I read somewhere stated that right around 50% of single lung hit deer live. I was so amazed by that I shared this with my wife, who is a nurse. She got this "you're saying something dumb again" look on her face and explained that all sorts of people live with 1 collapsed lung. Why would deer be any different?! You put a hole in the meat of a lung and that lung is pretty much toast. Slice the edge and it can continue to function. I wouldn't be the least bit surprised if you sliced the upper side of the near side lung, punched the opposite side and his near side lung is keeping him alive.
at 5.5, that buck is likely in his absolute physical prime. At the same time, he's been putting on fat, but yet to endure the stress of the rut. He's in peak condition that way, as well. Add it up and he's not going to die easy. Truly amazing animals.
P.S. all that said, your arrow inspection sounded like an above the spine hit...Now, I've center punched both lungs on a deer and had the arrow look like what you describe before. Still, the vast majority of lung hits look like lung hits.
Now that's a nice one Mo!
My brother is out there now, says buck activity went through the roof since the mercury fell.