Seedling ID

[Yarg]

I pulled these underneath the canopy of several large White Oaks..I was looking for some pros to i d hopefully you can make out from photos thanks

 

[Rubee]

Ash?

 

[chickenlittle]

Did it smell like anything?

 

[Yarg]

Did it smell like anything?

No unusual smell.. The more I look at the bigger ones they do to appear to be Ash.. he pulled way too easy to be Oaks I think..

 

[Rit]

The last photo of the twig in your hand that has the square end is a blue ash. The others also appear to be ash. I can’t see the other side of the bud on the others but looks to be black ash. I have millions of ash seedlings on my place and they grow well in the shade of giant oak trees.