Nice Tasting apple, and I will keep it because it seems like it is going to throw some every year. I've got a bushel to scrat this coming weekend for juice. I surely like this apple and have been bringing them into work last week and this. Even though they are good and ripe they still have a twinge of green apple which I really like...like it's a "fresh" note. I ate one of these after a SweetSixteen and liked it better. I seem to be the exception on this preference. The HoneyCrisps, PixieCruch and S16 do better in the popularity contest both at home and at work...I guess I need a little tart in my life. :)