I've seen this happen. For a number of hunters, getting a deer every year seems to be a validation of their "manhood" or that they're a good hunter. Desperate - to me - is not a good frame of mind to be in as a hunter. Safety concerns (of all sorts), breaking laws, etc. I know trespassing has happened locally, as well as shooting a nice buck after dark with a rifle on the last day of archery season here. It happened at another camp near ours on our mountain .... desperation to take that buck. I heard the truck flying down our mountain road that evening right after the shot. What "hunting skill" is required to shoot at night with headlights?? Some people just don't care.
I've feasted on tag soup some years, some from passing on deer, and some from just not seeing any deer. I never felt "less of a hunter" in any of those situations.