Yup...and I'm a die hard shed hunter....i might even like shed hunting a little more than bow hunting...lol. I have a pretty good sized collection for a PA shed hunter....but I have been fortunate enough to have multiple year histories with a few of the bucks whose sheds are in my collection. I have an eye for piecing together antler characteristics.
gotcha...either way...i still say they are definitely from the same buck! he's one helluva deer too...maybe if you guys don't get a tag on him you'll pick up his sheds again this year.