Please don’t think I’m being argumentative. I’m genuinely trying to pick your brain. That was a $40-60k ($100/hr rented) machine. Are you saying that there are other tasks the dozer just can’t do?
I think most of my equipment jobs are heavy duty, dirt moving, clearing and wide road (not “trail”) construction Maybe that has me biased.
Lots of machines can do a job. You have to know which one is best for
your job.
If you're making road in the woods, it's a dozer. If it's a road in the prairie, it's a motorgrader. If you need to do a lot of digging and not so much traveling, an excavator is the tool. If you need to do a little digging and a lot of traveling, a backhoe loader is the tool because it travels faster and can be roaded from dig to dig vs needing to be put on a trailer. If you need to spread a little material in a lot of places and level it out, the skid steer is the tool.
When it comes to most habitat work, the excavator is the most versatile. Its great for digging, grabbing, placing, stacking, burying. Nothing else can do that much. What an excavator is terrible at is moving material any distance. I had to dig pits next to my blind locations because I couldn't move dirt from where I wanted to take it, to where I needed it to make the elevated platforms. Now I have two large pits I need to fill with other stuff to eliminate the hazard of a hole in the woods.
One will eventually get dirt when I rent a skid steer, another can only be filled with junk wood because I don't have fill readily stacked (like what I'd have done with the excavator) anywhere nearby that I can use there. And frankly, if I move that blind someday, I want to be able to put the dirt back where it was. I already have a dirt pile from a previous blind location that I need to scoop up and put the dirt back from where it was taken.
You're asking great questions. Keep going. Figure out what you want to do first, then find the right tool to do it. But always be thinking about where you're gonna go with stuff, because when stuff starts moving, it has to go somewhere. I buried the entire forest underneath my new plot. Only tool that was gonna do all of that was the excavator.