We hired a forester and it was a great investment for us. We had some small sections of hardwoods clear-cut and a large block of pines thinned. We interviewed 3 different private foresters from a list we got from our county forester. Two of them seemed completely focused on maximizing timber income and paid lip service only to our desire for a plan that balanced timber income with wildlife management concerns. The third that we hired was great! He listened to us a lot and made recommendations with alternatives. He would say things like: "If you do this, you will get roughly $x more in timber sale but if you do that, it will be better for you wildlife management goals and here is why".
Don't be afraid to interview a number of foresters before selecting one. Things are different from state to state, but in our state, the department of forestry pays county foresters who will provide broad advice (not conduct or oversee sales). They also linked us up with state cost sharing programs for things like spraying. In addition, our game department has wildlife biologists who come out for free and provide advice. Finally, USDA NRCS has some conservation programs like EQUIP that we used. This offsets cost for things like putting in firebreaks, spraying herbicide, and conducting controlled burns. They too sent out wildlife biologists that help us assess and do some planning.
If your objective is primarily deer, I would not think of this in terms of logging. I would develop a long-term wildlife management plan and think of logging as one tool that may be useful in executing that plan.
Thanks,
jack