• If you are posting pictures, and they aren't posting in the correct orientation, please flush your browser cache and try again.

    Edge
    Safari/iOS
    Chrome

Is This The Same Buck?

SwampCat

5 year old buck +
Last year - both antler tips bent down. I hunted him pretty hard last year up into mid winter


Image



In the same area this year, I am getting pictures of this buck. If you cut those drop antler tips off from last year, I think he would be an exact match. Our deer tend to lose points as they pass five years old

Image


Image



same deer - or different?
 
Yes also. Too bad he shrunk.
 
Likely the same.
 
I agree, too bad he lost those cool beam tips.
 
Right side G2 rearward curve is a bit off this year. But that doesn’t mean anything I suppose. Either way that’s an old warrior and would be a trophy in my book.

Good luck catching him in the daytime. I’d say he’s old enough to wait for the ladies to find him.
 
I'd say not the same deer. Browtines are different, G2's don't curve the same, and G3's were considerably longer than G2's on the first buck but not on the second one. I see the similarities but would think maybe a brother or offspring to the original deer.
 
Last edited:
I'd agree. Not the same buck. Brows.
 
Yes. Same big fork and same crab claw.
 
I'd say not the same deer. Browtines are different, G2's don't curve the same, and G3's were considerably longer than G2's on the first buck but not on the second one. I see the similarities but would think maybe a brother or offspring to the original deer.
agreed, g2's and browtines are too different
 
Back
Top