Bittersweet ending

Brian662

5 year old buck +
Back on December 2nd I was fortunate enough to get an opportunity to take my first buck off the new property we purchased in SW WI. It was opening day of muzzle loader and I was hunting a pretty aggressive spot for the wind direction but after a fresh snow I was expecting to see one of the shooter bucks.

A doe and a fawn were milling around in the kill plot I was hunting over and then a small buck came to the opening on the timber edge. He was followed closely by a deer that I first saw the rack of. I put the binos on the buck and immediately saw the G2 kicker and knew which one it was. As I was trying to get the blind door open quietly and quickly (the doe&fawn were inside of 15 yards) the latch on the window caught and made a noise. The doe, fawn, and small buck took off and I thought I had blown my opportunity. The target buck had been broadside at 40 yards and he didn't know what happened so he walked a little deeper into the woods edge but stood broadside at 50. I am normally able to compose myself when getting shot opportunities but with the recent events I was pretty amped up. Because the buck shifted I had to open a different window while he is at high alert. I'm able to get the window open and settle my muzzle loader on his shoulder. Squeeze off a shot and drop him in his tracks. He does the typical squirm on the ground and then goes motionless. Awesome! I text my friend who I own the property with and he calls. So we talk for a few minutes and I can see the buck laying there motionless. I told him I would send pics when I get up to it. I pack up my gear and get down from the stand but I did reload the muzzle loader just in case...when I get to the spot he was laying, he is GONE. Amazed and in a slight panic I assess the situation and decide to back out, I can see the leave rustled from the fresh snow in the area he was struggling before going motionless.
I head back to the house and try to figure out wtf just happened. I come back up in an hour just after dark with my 4 wheeler and headlamp. I don't find any blood and pretty quickly lose his trail from the kicked over snow. Frustrated but no idea, I decided to call a drone to see if he could be located. I'm certain he just got a second wind and died somewhere nearby but I don't have any help and I'm supposed to be at work in the AM.
The drone shows up about 5 hours after I shot him and within 20 minutes we locate him walking about 600 yards from where I shot him!!! I'm completely amazed at this point, but the buck beds down and he gets a few photos of the buck with his spotlight. Law says the drone can't help me locate a wounded deer that hasn't died, so the operator had to back out and I'm on my own.
Here was the view from drone.IMG_20241202_222926.jpg
The shot was higher than I'd hoped, i think the chaos that ensued caused me to rush a bit and I forgot my muzzleloader is zeroed at 100 so it would shoot a few inches high at 50 yards.
Screenshot_20241229_222250_Gallery.jpg

When I saw the Pic from the drone, my first thought was "he's a dead deer". But i decided to wait for daylight when I could get a friend to come help. Next morning we set off into the direction I believe he was bedded. After 1.5 hours we find the bed and some blood but no deer. Following the trail he walked but without blood there was another bed about 80 yards away. Now I'm thinking what kind of wounded deer beds twice in a 80 yard stretch without being significantly hurt. We continue to look for 4 hours but the majority of people I contacted thought the hit was non fatal above the spine. Not knowing what to do or where to go, we decide to pull the plug and wait to watch if he shows back up on cameras.
With every passing day of no pics, I'm more and more convinced he's dead, but I don’t know where. Concerned we bumped him when looking and he's dead a 1/2 mile away...

Fast forward to this weekend and able to get back down there for the first time since the hunt, I secured permission from the neighbor to search his property in the direction he was headed when we gave up the search. My friend's son came up on him this morning about 400 yards from where his last bed was, 200 yards across the property line. Finally, closure.
My guess was he was dead already when we were looking in the morning but we just didn't know where to go and I didn't have permission to look on the neighbors.
I guess the coyotes have to eat once in a while too but I wish this wasn't the ending. 20241229_104049.jpg
My guess is he's 5 years old but I didn't have any history to say for certain. 23 3/4" inside spread. Will have him measured at the taxidermist.

Here is a photo of his rack and my archery kill from WI. The archery kill was 151 1/8. Any guess on the score for this one?

20241229_211919.jpg
 
That's brutal. I'm sorry man. I had a similar experience this fall except there were too many leaves and we didn't find him with the drone. I'm sure he's dead and we'll find him shed hunting, but that doesnt get it done.

Glad you got your hands on him and yes, i'd agree, hit high, shocked the central nervous system enough to put him down and then he got up. I've done it myself.
 
Is there any chance he walked around for a few weeks before expiring? Doesn't look that heavily scavenged on. I would've expected nothing but skeletal remains after nearly a month. Just a thought. In any event, sorry you lost him but glad you recovered him eventually. Happens to everyone at some point.
 
Is there any chance he walked around for a few weeks before expiring? Doesn't look that heavily scavenged on. I would've expected nothing but skeletal remains after nearly a month. Just a thought. In any event, sorry you lost him but glad you recovered him eventually. Happens to everyone at some point.
I don't think so. He is pretty well scavenged on, his whole side was gone. We also had 6" of snow and single digit temps for 10 of those days so he was probably pretty frozen for a good period.
 
Happens but makes me glad for you that you found him! Closure always good thing.

Great wide rack. Congrats.
 
What bullet did you use? That shot isn’t that high. Unless you were below him when you shot I can’t see how that went above the spine.

Here is entrance of my deer yesterday. High shoulder shot. Went below the spine.


IMG_5847.jpeg
 
Hate to see this happen, but eventually it will. Glad you found him and it's important to expend that effort to locate them. Nice to get closure.
 
Glad you finally got him back.

Were you using Powerbelts by chance?
 
Barnes TMZ with 100g of blackhorn powder
 
What bullet did you use? That shot isn’t that high. Unless you were below him when you shot I can’t see how that went above the spine.

Here is entrance of my deer yesterday. High shoulder shot. Went below the spine.


View attachment 72604
I'd say I was about level with him. The first bed he laid in there was blood on both sides of the bed. Tough animals, man...it's crazy.
 
Barnes TMZ with 100g of blackhorn powder

Is it possible the bullet struck a tree or a branch before it hit the deer?
 
Is it possible the bullet struck a tree or a branch before it hit the deer?
I was in a field and he was in the woods, so yes, I'd say it was possible but I had a very clear view of him from what I could see.
 
I was in a field and he was in the woods, so yes, I'd say it was possible but I had a very clear view of him from what I could see.

I agree with Omicron. That shot doesn't look that high. Also with Mortenson...I know you said it was cold for 10 days, but any deer around here with a heavy coyote population would be gone in days.

I'll throw one more possibility out there. Can't tell you how many deer I've seen with old muzzloader bullets in their shoulder or ribs from incomplete ignition or semi-dry powder. Was your charge fresh that morning? Or had it been in the rifle sitting uncapped for days prior? From everything you described, it sounds like you either hit a branch, or that bullet wasn't travelling fast enough.

Sorry about that buck Brian. Great deer. Glad you found him. But always bittersweet as you said when you don't get to enjoy the meat and celebrate a clean, quick kill.
 
I shot this tank at 40 yards with a 12 gauge slug back in '15 after a good November snow storm. Expected to find him easily. After following blood through the snow for a hundred yards, I jumped him. Came back at dawn. Found where he bedded most likely all the night. Didn't find this deer. Like you, I think I must've hit high. I had to rush my shot. We had a somewhat similar looking buck on the farm the next 2 yrs, ultimately finding his remains. Never could decide if it was him or not. Is it possible to have DNA sampled from antler? I wanted that buck - after being whacked by ehd in '12 & '13, he was the 1st mature buck to hunt again. Still bothered by it.

SUNP0124.jpeg20151123_110109.jpg20151123_110219.jpg20151123_110247.jpg
 
I agree with Omicron. That shot doesn't look that high. Also with Mortenson...I know you said it was cold for 10 days, but any deer around here with a heavy coyote population would be gone in days.

I'll throw one more possibility out there. Can't tell you how many deer I've seen with old muzzloader bullets in their shoulder or ribs from incomplete ignition or semi-dry powder. Was your charge fresh that morning? Or had it been in the rifle sitting uncapped for days prior? From everything you described, it sounds like you either hit a branch, or that bullet wasn't travelling fast enough.

Sorry about that buck Brian. Great deer. Glad you found him. But always bittersweet as you said when you don't get to enjoy the meat and celebrate a clean, quick kill.
I keep going back to two beds within 80 yards only hours after the shot, thats not normal deer behavior, he was hurt badly. I didn't take many pics of the corpse but here's another one that shows he was pretty well eaten up. They got about everything but the neck.

20241229_103939.jpg

It was the first day of muzzle loader season. Loaded the round in the blind that day. If anything I'd say it could have hit a branch, but not sure.
 
I'd say I was about level with him. The first bed he laid in there was blood on both sides of the bed. Tough animals, man...it's crazy.
Happens with high shoulder. It probably shocked the spine but didn’t actually damage it. You most likely went above the lungs and heart but below the spine.

My grandad shot a deer one time and they loaded in truck. They then went to eat. While eating it got up and ran off! Happens.

Always a risk with a drt shot. It’s shot I take too but double lung is always lethal. They just often run.
 
Also why I have moved away from Barnes bullets, especially for a spine shot. Monos just pencil through. I use only frangible bullets now, the shrapnel gives a better chance of taking out spine or vitals with less than perfect shot.
 
This is where the shot was.View attachment 72610
Were you going for a spine/high shoulder or just shot high with all the commotion? I still get buck fever so believe me I know!

Reason I ask is it seems spine shot works best a good bit more anteriorly, straight up front leg through scapula.
 
Were you going for a spine/high shoulder or just shot high with all the commotion? I still get buck fever so believe me I know!

Reason I ask is it seems spine shot works best a good bit more anteriorly, straight up front leg through scapula.
I was going for mid body even with the back of the front leg. I didn't take into account that I'm zero'd at 100 and the shot was only ~50. So between the chaos and the closer range, I think I hit about 4" higher than I was aiming.
 
Back
Top