Bumping this thread to 2025, Planning for some hybrid willow cuttings on both sides of my 100 foot road accross the swamp. Maybe some dogwood too. How many should I plan for? Can I "get away" with planting into the existing grasses in the swamp? (monoculture of swamp grass about 2 feet high) Not sure I can do this work myself....may hire some high school kids to help me. Pic to show the grass I have to deal with. suggestions and ideas are
helpful....thanks!View attachment 85847
Rather than plant into the grasses....could I plant into the sand....just where it meets that swamp grass?? Maybe a treatment of roundup before planting the cuttings?
Foggy,
I tried planting into existing grasses - zero percent survival after year 1. They just didn’t take. I’d run a 3’ weed mat where your road meets the swamp. I think in the 45 degree angle of the road will be too dry or you will need longer cuttings increasing cost.
The weed matt will keep the plantings clean and free from weeds for the foreseeable future, and you’ll never have to weed whack that area.
Would black plastic be a cheaper alternative? You would still need some landscape staples like with fabric.^ Thanks for this advice. Been concerned on what to do here. I have a sickle bar mower that could cut the grasses to about 4 or 5 feet from the road bank. Then could hit it with glyphosate and run that suggested weed mat along the same path.....and finally plant the cuttings into the junction of the road with my swampland.
Not sure of the weed mat yet....but does this sound like a reasonable plan? I suppose I need 200 yards of weed mat. Source??
Bumping this thread to 2025, Planning for some hybrid willow cuttings on both sides of my 100 foot road accross the swamp. Maybe some dogwood too. How many should I plan for? Can I "get away" with planting into the existing grasses in the swamp? (monoculture of swamp grass about 2 feet high) Not sure I can do this work myself....may hire some high school kids to help me. Pic to show the grass I have to deal with. suggestions and ideas are
helpful....thanks!View attachment 85847
Rather than plant into the grasses....could I plant into the sand....just where it meets that swamp grass?? Maybe a treatment of roundup before planting the cuttings?
I'd think you could plant into the bottom edge of the sand. That entire grassy area looks like a great spot to plant some tamarack as well. I bet they would thrive in that open sun. I see LOTS of rubs on tamaracks. They'd grow quick and help fill in that low area. I see places around me that seem like wet bogs that have tamarack growing in them.
In my bog, the wettest areas are filled with the swamp grasses like you have. The slightly drier areas have tamaracks and black spruce. The driest areas have a mix of tamarack, black spruce, wetland shrubs and young birch. If you don't already have tamarack or black spruce growing there, I'm guessing it is too wet (unless for some reason your bog was cut in winter or burned recently to prevent tree growth).That always surprised me too. I do have other nearby bog areas where tamaracks are thriving....but not in this bog. Not sure why that is. May be worth a try.

@Foggy47 I planted a row of hybrid willows the past two years at my place in pretty wet ground. Was mostly reed canary grass and sandbar willows growing there. I just mowed a strip with the flail mower and rolled out 4' weed mat fabric in a straight line. Then i cut little slits in the fabric and dibbled in rooted cuttings. They have taken well but i didn't protect them so they have gotten browsed hard. Not enough to kill them but they are not getting tall.. The seedlings from cold stream farms are priced like cuttings (64 cents ea if over 100) and i think have much higher odds of doing well but are more involved to plant. https://www.coldstreamfarm.net/product/hybrid-willow-salix/
This is best pic I could find from a few weeks after planting this spring. View attachment 86125
Prayers sent for both of you, foggy.^ Thanks for all the inputs here guys. Good info. Considering all. Gotta say, I am looking for cheap and easy......and even at easy.....I don't have much juice to put into this project. Seems each year I may lose 1/3 or more of my strength and ability. Strange how that happens. Gonna have to hire some kids to do this work. Maybe I can make a few new young friends? But Having a plan, organizing, and supervising the kids seems fundamental to success for this project.
Like so many things....I wish I would have done this sooner. It is what it is. I am grateful to have this project at its current state. At this point this project(s) is more like a diversion from everyday life for me....and away from dealing with my wife's health issues. She is going thru some tough times due to congestive heart failure. Not gaining on it. Projects like this give me some relief from these concerns.....and something else to do.
Over the weekend, I decided to give up my plan for a new product development and patent I had. Simply not worth the time and effort in light of where we are in life. Gotta pick my battles. Been a long road.
Thanks for all the ideas shared here. Helps to have such good guys here that offer up their experience in such things.....and good advice and some fun things to plan for the future.
An old saying I once read rings true: "Plan plans....not results". We keep planning. Results may vary. Hug your wife tonight. :)
Looks like a good source and price ($1.10 each)....but they pretty short at 12". Is that enough? I think I can plant them at the waterline.....so I suppose it is enough. (I answered my own question. grin). Tubes required? I may tube those nearest the shoreline and leave them bare in the middle. Thinking I should plant them every 10 feet.....and then make my own cuttings from these hybrids in future years.Iowa State Forrest Nursery