Dolgo are somewhat more true to seed than most apples so I grew some from seed. I also ordered scions from GRIN. This should ensure exact dolgo characteristics on a full sized tree and speed time to fruit.
I ordered a couple dozen dolgo seedlings from chief river nursery a month ago. I've never purchased from them before, but they seemed pretty affordable so it was worth a shot
You will definitely have some variability in seedling Dolgo, not saying that is a bad thing, just saying you will. I normally have grafted Dolgo but I am sold out for this spring.
I am sorry to side-track this thread but I saw Willis Orchard mentioned. I bought from them in 2010. This is American Crab from Willis 2010. The fruit load was great. I ended up support bracing branches with long forked sticks rather than thinning as I feared the branches would break. But no broken branches. Tree bare-all-dropped by Mid-December. 2 pics, bloom and ripe-fruit.
So you're saying they are both Dolgo but that is the variation due to planting from seed rather than grafting? Were the original seeds from the same tree?