Food plot location strategy poll - numerous kill plots (<0.25 ac) or larger feeder plots (>1.0 ac) throughout property

Would you rather more numerous but smaller plots (~0.25 ac) or larger feeder plots (>1.0 ac)?

  • Several smaller plots (~0.25 acres) scattered around the property

    Votes: 4 21.1%
  • Fewer, but larger feeder plots (>1.0 acres) centered within the property

    Votes: 15 78.9%

  • Total voters
    19
I have both. And I see bucks way more at the small kill plots. They only go into big fields in middle of night or rut. Even in rut ive seen them come to edge and blow and scratch but never come out into the field.

Where I am is mainly timber and not much big ag. So I think they just find big open fields scary.
Do deer flow in the direction of your big plots or ag fields in the evening?
 
Do deer flow in the direction of your big plots or ag fields in the evening?
There are no ag fields for miles and miles.

My large plots have deer in them from about an hour until dark until and hour or two after sunrise. I often see 10 plus deer anytime I check camera or sit in shooting house.

That said, almost never a buck until after dark. Even then I see them more in the 0.5-1 acre fields that are surrounded by thicker stuff
 
I used to have a lease in Louisiana with about 25 plots spread across 2100 acres ranging in size from .25 to 1.5 acres. It was aggravating to move between each one. I also think it alerted more deer. And, I had bucks that would use several different ones. I always planted them with the same mixes. When I bought property in Kentucky, I started with 3 plots on 40 acres. I've narrowed it to one big one. I may add a small one in between it and bedding. I only have about 50 acres now though. But, I find it easier to hunt a property with concentrated food attraction and designated bedding.
 
Ideally - Fewer bigger food plots with good access to locations between them and bedding. The food plot doesn't need to be the stand location but rather keep deer around and create predictable movement. Like has been mentioned, can have narrow or small more secure entrances to them for deer to work their way towards the bigger destination.

Hard to have predictable movement and good access when stuff is scattered everywhere.
 
I used to have a lease in Louisiana with about 25 plots spread across 2100 acres ranging in size from .25 to 1.5 acres. It was aggravating to move between each one. I also think it alerted more deer. And, I had bucks that would use several different ones. I always planted them with the same mixes. When I bought property in Kentucky, I started with 3 plots on 40 acres. I've narrowed it to one big one. I may add a small one in between it and bedding. I only have about 50 acres now though. But, I find it easier to hunt a property with concentrated food attraction and designated bedding.
This is exactly how it works at my place. I have 11 food plots and I may have a picture of one buck in all 11 plots over the course of three days. My neighbor 1/2 mile south will have a picture of the same buck at his feeder as will my neighbor 1/4 mile north. The neighbors are much more likely to kill him - as they have one place to hunt on their ten acres - so they are more likely to be there when the buck shows up. I am trying to decide which of 11 food plots to hunt, plus I have some stands on trails and crossings, etc. My chances of having an encounter with the same buck is slim.

I have been thinking about this more - I have 3 food plots under one acre in size. Eight over one acre in size. We have never killed a deer out of any of the three smaller plots - that is over the past ten to 20 years. We have killed multiple deer out of the eight larger plots. This isnt because deer dont come to the smaller plots - but they dont come there consistently enough to feel as confident about hunting there as one of the larger food plots. That is how my place works.
 
These experiences have been pretty helpful and have given me things to consider.

I'm frankly more concerned with access than I am with huntability. I've been wondering about this for a farm that is less than 200 acres, which likely changes things. I think having predictable deer movement is something you can plan around in the future and build off-of. If they can be anywhere, you will never know if changes you are making to your farm are for the better or worse until a season or two after.
 
I just have my plots there to help give the deer options and maybe add to the dinner menu for them and maybe help keep the deer around on the property. I don't really hunt my plots. I might take a peek once in awhile to see if any deer are in the plots but food isn't really their top priority during the rut. Maybe I'll go back to hunting the plots if I start bow hunting again. Strictly rifle for the last few years for me.
 
I just have my plots there to help give the deer options and maybe add to the dinner menu for them and maybe help keep the deer around on the property. I don't really hunt my plots. I might take a peek once in awhile to see if any deer are in the plots but food isn't really their top priority during the rut. Maybe I'll go back to hunting the plots if I start bow hunting again. Strictly rifle for the last few years for me.
I agree - plots arent primary focus for bucks during the rut - but they are for does. The bucks we kill during the rut are checking on the does in the plots
 
These experiences have been pretty helpful and have given me things to consider.

I'm frankly more concerned with access than I am with huntability. I've been wondering about this for a farm that is less than 200 acres, which likely changes things. I think having predictable deer movement is something you can plan around in the future and build off-of. If they can be anywhere, you will never know if changes you are making to your farm are for the better or worse until a season or two after.
For grins, I had Brooks Johnson do a skeletal aerial plan for my place at 100 $

I learned more from the 20 min audio than from the entire book series of some authors

He states that improvements ( food plots, etc) should be based on access and how the deer bed on your property

He used LIDAR apps to determine slopes,topo, etc where deer are most likely to bed

Its worth a look

bill
 
For grins, I had Brooks Johnson do a skeletal aerial plan for my place at 100 $

I learned more from the 20 min audio than from the entire book series of some authors

He states that improvements ( food plots, etc) should be based on access and how the deer bed on your property

He used LIDAR apps to determine slopes,topo, etc where deer are most likely to bed

Its worth a look

bill
Curious - did he consider bedding areas, slopes, topo, habitat type and adjacent property owner use - OFF your property?
 
Curious - did he consider bedding areas, slopes, topo, habitat type and adjacent property owner use - OFF your property?

Not really

I didn't provide adjacent property owner use

He commented on the other topics briefly but focused on my place

Another set of eyes from a different perspective was helpful to me

bill
 
Not really

I didn't provide adjacent property owner use

He commented on the other topics briefly but focused on my place

Another set of eyes from a different perspective was helpful to me

bill
$100 pretty reasonable for another perspective.
 
Each property is unique. On my place, give me big linear destination plots (3+ acres) over micro plots - (1/2 acre or less). My largest is just over 5 acres. Son counted 26 deer in field at same time last Sunday before dark. Micro plots may have 1 doe group in em at a time. Largest plot has 6 stand sets, depending on gun or bow and wind.

Don’t hunt em much during the rut but from December thru end of season in mid Jan, the deer pile into the destination plots at any time of the day and particularly late afternoons.
 
Each property is unique. On my place, give me big linear destination plots (3+ acres) over micro plots - (1/2 acre or less). My largest is just over 5 acres. Son counted 26 deer in field at same time last Sunday before dark. Micro plots may have 1 doe group in em at a time. Largest plot has 6 stand sets, depending on gun or bow and wind.

Don’t hunt em much during the rut but from December thru end of season in mid Jan, the deer pile into the destination plots at any time of the day and particularly late afternoons.
Exactly what I see.
 
Fewer bigger plots let’s you put nice enclosed blinds on them. 3 plots with weatherproof / scent proof blinds is affordable. 10 plots not so much. Even in a big plot - the deer usually are going to come out from 1 or 2 locations.
 
Top