No experience with black haw, but American Beautyberry is native to my area in LA. The stuff grows everywhere and does fine in the shade and in drains, it’s usually a major component in the understory of pine plantations around here. It grows pretty fast and will quickly thicken up an area, especially with all the berries they produce and the way it sends out shoots. I’ve never seen deer browse on it, but I’ve heard of people seeing it happen. The leaves can be used as a mosquito repellent, by crushing the leaves and rubbing it on your skin. Works pretty well, as it puts off a strong odor.
I’ve got the stuff everywhere, so I’m not the biggest fan of it. But it definitely has its place, and continues to provide cover for me. The deer have trails all through the stuff, so it serves its purpose.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk