I'm with Native, I have doubts on 4.5.
3.5 is a darn nice deer. 5.5 is getting stupid looking. The nose on that deer is very Roman. The brisket has a single breast in the summer which never seems to be mentioned but sticks out to me. I'm willing to bet in 6 maybe more like 8 weeks the breast will be swallowed by his neck. :).
Let's just say he's a pig and he's over 5 years old. Don't care what the antlers look like, that's a trophy. I hope you get to send his teeth in to have him aged.
On a side note, My neighbor is selling I can't swallow it all and he won't break it up. If I get the wrong neighbor I'm coming to KY. Closer to home and I can maybe still afford it!