Crabapple timeline

Thank you Art! I'd never blame you. I think I speak for everyone when I say we appreciate your knowledge and everything you bring to this forum!

I don’t know if it is knowledge. It has mostly been just trial and error with mostly crabs at my place.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Yes I picked up two yellow dog’s and two big dogs’s quite a few others also. The trees I got from him last year are probably some of the best I planted last year with the exception of couple Sundance I got from Gurney’s since I couldn’t find them anywhere else, those things grow like crazy.
 
I don’t know if it is knowledge. It has mostly been just trial and error with mostly crabs at my place.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Knowledge comes from experience and we appreciate you sharing it :emoji_wink:
 
There are pictures somewhere in this thread.

Two years ago, I had two yearling bucks under it during the Opening morning of our Nov. rifle hunt. I have two other top works that are producing, also.

This tree is on the end of a row of flowering crabs that I planted about 30 plus years ago. There is a grandma eating apple on the other end of the row. I still don’t know if this is a Grandma seedling crab or a stray from the SWCD flowering crab order.

Bows has a fast growing seedling from it.
This timing is perfect. The Yellow Dog seedling Bur is referring to ............. I just NOW measured it again. A few weeks ago I reported here that it had grown from 51" to 54" tall. Just now I measured it again - it seemed taller ........ and it's NOW 58" tall.

I HAVE NOT fertilized it at all - it's just growing in a pot in my back yard. The potting medium is a mix of potting soil, compost, a TINY bit of sand, and a little bit of our native clayish topsoil. All mixed together ......... and no fertilizer - only water. Our days recently have been a mix of clouds and sun, temps from mid-60's to upper 70's, with a few very light rains of short duration.

That's the environment Bur's Y.D. seedling - the tallest one of his seedlings I have in pots - has been exposed to. Bottom trunk dia. is 1/2". I'd say it's a grower.

I'll add that Sandbur has been - AND IS - a top-flight, first class gentleman. Many thanks for his sharing of info, experience, pics, seeds/seedlings, .......... the whole shooting match. My personal thanks for his contributions to ME in all of the above-mentioned aspects - not the least of which is his convincing me to lean toward crabs for deer. My hat is off, Art !!!!!!!!
 
Knowledge comes from experience and we appreciate you sharing it :emoji_wink:

......And Sandbur is being modest

his generosity with his wealth of experience has been a treasure to us all

bill
 
I stopped by after to work to check out this apple/crab. It’s right by an overpass. Not many falling yet but it is loaded. Going to keep my eye on it and see when it drops the majority of its apples
 

Attachments

  • 655DEE49-550C-423E-B83B-D116A32A0863.jpeg
    655DEE49-550C-423E-B83B-D116A32A0863.jpeg
    953.1 KB · Views: 44
  • 707CB968-7A06-4892-B21E-02C9EE00797E.jpeg
    707CB968-7A06-4892-B21E-02C9EE00797E.jpeg
    838.5 KB · Views: 43
  • 6A038767-C18A-47D2-BD1C-C7B7CFDE2957.jpeg
    6A038767-C18A-47D2-BD1C-C7B7CFDE2957.jpeg
    912.6 KB · Views: 46
  • B9ABAD02-2ABF-400B-BDDF-BA573416D139.jpeg
    B9ABAD02-2ABF-400B-BDDF-BA573416D139.jpeg
    770.3 KB · Views: 45
  • CF306AA0-1A2E-4FBD-9794-CAE6979D65E0.jpeg
    CF306AA0-1A2E-4FBD-9794-CAE6979D65E0.jpeg
    784 KB · Views: 45
  • 9FAEB174-27A3-4A23-9937-0FC4E8647A7B.jpeg
    9FAEB174-27A3-4A23-9937-0FC4E8647A7B.jpeg
    333.8 KB · Views: 45
I wonder how much difference rootstock makes in the growth.

I want to point out that those trees from my place are not trademarked or patented or whatever the name is. I make no profit from their sale. I have chosen to do it this way. You can cut scion or buds from them at anytime.

I share my experiences here and would like feedback, as the trees probably WILL perform differently in different climates and with different soils. If/when they don’t work out on other deer acres, please don’t blame me. We are just trying to learn together.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

We all just really appreciate you sharing your tree information and scion wood. Also appreciate you letting Ryan propagate your trees for sale so others can benefit. Means a lot for us in our habitat efforts.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
09d8c21ee9046735c4a086b27f33f503.jpg

There are some interesting comments from Lois in this thread if anyone wants to look it up. It is from 2014. I think the thread was titled Zone 3 Apple Tree Recommendations for Deer.

She discussed B118 and dolgo rootstock. She also says that Willamette Valley was providing clinal dolgo while other use dolgo seedlings.

She also felt B118 was good for wildlife . My B118’s had their first fruit this year. Not a heavy crop and the trees were quite old before bearing fruit.

Maybe someone has a better way to copy the link.

She also discussed pear rootstock for deer.

Some of us have been around here a long time! We even go back to the previous QDMA forum before they shut it down.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
c57cdd57502fc644ef1d6f8adaa50157.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
85bc079df91ae3990c768d74f9081f06.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Lois suggests that deer prefer apples over crabs. That has not been my experience, but I have mostly crabs.

I feel the crabs are more bite sized. It may be a preference thing that develops after repeated exposure to one or the other. Perhaps like some deer adjusting to turnips.

I still feel that crabs are easier to grow in my climate.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
In regard to Lois' info & her opinion that deer will go after "people apples" first over crab apples - could it be because "people apples" are bred for sweetness?? Crabs are GENERALLY more tart than "people apples" - so could that be the source of her experiences??

In my experience - here - deer go for both crabs and "people apples." However, deer do seem to have preferences for certain apples over other ones - for whatever reason. As long as they're coming to the trees, I don't worry about their preferences too much.

As for B-118 rootstocks - in our soil, some of the B-118 trees are leaning .......... though not all. Don't know why some lean and others don't.
 
Last edited:
9c1cd6f0ec65713033236519edf74ead.jpg

I think we have a false Jonsib here. My buddy and I both received scion from GRIN and now have a similar apple that doesn’t match the description, but matches their picture.

I have three of these apples on a limb on a flowering crab. I had to work hard to pull it off, so it appears to be a late dropper. There is no sign of disease. It is very juicy, crisp, and somewhat acid. It was at early watercore. I think this would make a great cooking apple, as well as an addition to cider.

I left the other two apples to evaluate drop time. This year is an oddity with drop times, probably due to drought and heat.

So , this must be a GRIN Jonsib.

Does anyone have a picture of Jonsib?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
9c1cd6f0ec65713033236519edf74ead.jpg

I think we have a false Jonsib here. My buddy and I both received scion from GRIN and now have a similar apple that doesn’t match the description, but matches their picture.

I have three of these apples on a limb on a flowering crab. I had to work hard to pull it off, so it appears to be a late dropper. There is no sign of disease. It is very juicy, crisp, and somewhat acid. It was at early watercore. I think this would make a great cooking apple, as well as an addition to cider.

I left the other two apples to evaluate drop time. This year is an oddity with drop times, probably due to drought and heat.

So , this must be a GRIN Jonsib.

Does anyone have a picture of Jonsib?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

26cde28deeda28a8b2e21e03c78ac1b5.jpg

Nice white flesh and crispy on the ‘ :) ‘Jonsib’.

I think the GRIN website says apple size is 45mm, but then shows a picture of an apple at 7cm.
 
Sandbur,

Could you describe the flavor (sweet, tart, astringency) of both your Buckman & Bigdog compared to Kerr?

Thanks
 
Sandbur,

Could you describe the flavor (sweet, tart, astringency) of both your Buckman & Bigdog compared to Kerr?

Thanks

I am not real good at describing these tastes.

I like crab apples, and for my tastes, Big Dog is inedible. It is very hard. I have thrown a few in a cider blend. I would recommend it only for the deer. Because it is so hard, I feel it lasts longer through the winter before getting mushy. I will add, in my climate.

I can eat Buckman and have also used it in cider. Tart for sure and too tart for many people.

For an eating crab, there are better choices. Chestnut crab and Kerr.

Trailman Crab was exceptionally good this year, but it is an early crab.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
ca4c9695d25545c2f2fffb4ff5775f43.jpg

Current picture of Big Dog.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

How old is that tree?

What size are the crab apples?

I have multiple Big Dogs coming next spring so excited to see that pic.
 
How old is that tree?

What size are the crab apples?

I have multiple Big Dogs coming next spring so excited to see that pic.

The apples are about 1 3/4 inches long.

Big Dog grew from the roots of a tree that was here when we bought the farm, about 35 years ago. I suspect it is a rootstock crab as I have seen it under a red splendor crab.

It seems like the rabbits and deer got it once after the top died, then I protected the next regrowth for a few years until it got bigger.

I hope Big Dog works for you, especially if you ordered a bunch of them. Different climates/soils might give different results.

My suspicion is that it is some sort of Columbia Crab seedling.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
  • Like
Reactions: J B
Top